So needless to say 2020 has been a pretty trash year, however it does boast one thing that I don’t think any other year can, my two favorite bands released new albums within a week of each other. That being The Lemon Twigs with Songs For The General Public and The Killers with Imploding the Mirage. I’ve got a lot of mixed feelings about both of these albums, but I’m not really interested in how good these albums are (because spoiler alert, they’re both pretty good). No, I want to know which one is better. So let’s take a look into both of these projects, shall we?
Let’s start with Songs For The General Public. This is definitely an album that grows on you, especially if you’re familiar with The Lemon Twigs’ normal sound. I went in expecting Do Hollywood part 2, that’s not it chief. Songs For The General Public is very experimental to say the least, there isn’t really a set sound that unites it and it’s kind of a hodgepodge of different genres. The biggest thing that makes it feel so disjointed is the stark contrast between Michael and Brian’s songs. All of Michael’s songs are very straightforward retro rock ballads, all about sex, love, breakups, drama, you know, what you expect from an epic rock song. If you just listen to songs like Moon, Hell On Wheels and Hog it really does sound like a cohesive album. I’d also like to add that it’s super cool that they released different versions of Fight, and the two that I’ve heard are both fantastic. Then on the flip side you’ve got Brian’s songs. Now, Brian’s songs have always been a bit experimental. In interviews they’ve both said that nobody could make music that sounds the way that Brian’s songs do, and I completely agree, nobody else could’ve made songs that sound like The Bully or Haroomata. But the thing about experiments is that sometimes they don’t work, and the thing about his songs on this album is that there are so many sounds happening at once and it’s kinda overstimulating. I think the two biggest offenders of this are Somebody Loving you and Only a Fool. I actually really like Somebody Loving You, but it took like 5 listens to realize that because there’s just so much going on, and I think the thing that makes me like it so much isn’t the music, it’s how good Brian’s vocals are in it, and I didn’t realise how great he sounded on it at first because of just how busy it is. Then on the other side is Only a Fool, the worst song on the album, you can’t convince me otherwise, it just is. It’s just as busy as Somebody Loving You, but it’s really weird and chaotic and it feels really out of place. Also, while Michael’s songs all sound like they came from the same album, Brian’s definitely don’t like the difference between The One and Only a Fool is night and day. I admire how ambitious his songs were, but it just didn’t work for me. Overall, I do think this is a good album, but you have to go in with an open mind and be prepared to not like it that much on the first listen. Once you hear all the little nuances and small details that are in it it really does help you appreciate it more.
Alright, so Imploding the Mirage. If you just look at the album cover you know exactly what you’re greeting yourself into, a project that is really focused on the aesthetics of its setting. Imagery and descriptiveness are things that The Killers have always been pretty good at, but this album dials it up to 11. This is about the desert and how lonely and beautiful it can be, and it won’t let you forget that. The only problem is that for me, sometimes aesthetic sounding music is boring? That’s why I’m not a huge fan of more lofi stuff, call me shallow but I’m a sucker for theatrics, and the fact that The Killers are so good at being theatrical is what made me love them so much. That’s not to say that this album is boring, but there definitely are a few luls. Personally, I think the slowest points in the album are Blowback, Lightning Fields, Fire in Bone and Running Towards a Place, the last three are all in a row, so it makes the middle drag a little bit. But oh boy, the beginning and the end are fantastic! I didn’t initially like My Own Soul’s Warning and Dying Breed but I grew to really love them, and I don’t care what anyone says, Caution is a bop and I love it. And the last three songs are *chefs kiss* just perfect. My God is super catchy and it leans more on the dramatic side kind of building up the momentum, then When Dreams Run Dry comes in and has all of the theatrical vocals that I love that really only Caution came close to, and though it’s kinda cheesy I think Imploding the Mirage was a great closer and it ended the album on a bang. This was a very good record, but the middle was just a little too slow for me to really love it.
Alright, so now that all of my thoughts are out there, which one is better? Well listening to them back to back made me realize that although they’re both good albums, there was never really a competition, it’s Songs for the General Public. I think that Songs for the General Public definitely has lower lows than Imploding the Mirage, but it also has higher highs, and I’m not neutral on any of the songs, they all evoke an emotional response from me, and that’s not quite something I can say about ITM. I also think it takes a lot more risks, I really admire how ambitious it was and I think that ITM definitely takes a few risks as well, it has more featured artists than any other The Killers album, but I don’t think they were substantial enough to have a really high risk high reward ratio. Overall, I think these are both solid albums and I’d highly recommend checking them both out.